When Smart Gets Lazy
E28

When Smart Gets Lazy

Summary

In this episode of "AI Made Easy for Business," Jeremy and Jim dive into an MIT study exploring how overreliance on AI tools like ChatGPT may diminish critical thinking and lead to "cognitive debt." They unpack the distinction between using AI as a tutor versus a crutch and share real-world examples—including Jim’s personal health transformation—of how technology can support, but not replace, thoughtful human effort. From AI-written one-liners to online leadership courses, this episode offers both caution and inspiration for anyone navigating AI’s expanding role in work and life.

THE AI JOKE

"What do you call a computer's favorite snack? Microchips."

TAKEAWAYS

  • Use AI as a tool, not a crutch. Critical thinking must stay in the driver’s seat.
  • The MIT study showed overreliance on AI may cause cognitive decline if users stop engaging mentally.
  • Switching from “brain-only” to “brain + AI” yielded short-term gains—if used responsibly.
  • Copy/paste AI use may save time but risks long-term skill atrophy and reduced creativity.
  • The best AI use is like having a sparring partner—one that helps refine your thinking, not replace it.
  • Leaders should set guardrails to help teams use AI responsibly and transparently.
  • Tools like ChatGPT handle complicated tasks; humans still shine in complex ones involving ambiguity and judgment.
  • Jim’s fitness journey illustrates how AI tools can support personal growth, but effort and human insight are essential.
  • Online courses can help teams cultivate critical thinking—essential in an AI-driven world.
  • Don’t automate wisdom; automate grunt work.

CHAPTERS

00:00 – The AI Joke & One-Liners
03:00 – MIT Study: AI, Critical Thinking, and Cognitive Debt
07:00 – Balanced AI Use vs. Copy-Paste Culture
10:00 – AI as Tutor, Not a Crutch (Language Learning Example)
13:00 – Jim’s Fitness Journey: Tools vs. Shortcuts
16:00 – Leadership and Critical Thinking in AI Use
18:00 – Complex vs. Complicated Tasks
22:00 – Human Wonder & Strategic Thinking
24:00 – Warnings for Overreliance and Corporate Layoffs
26:00 – Tools: Online Courses for Critical Thinking and Leadership

TOOLS

Online courses for employees and managers (and both who want to become leaders):

FREE

UC Davis: Critical Thinking Skills for the Professional: https://www.coursera.org/learn/critical-thinking-skills-for-professionals

  • Certificate, free course
  • Apply critical thinking skills to complex problems.
  • Apply a model for solving problems and pose questions to further understanding of specific problems.

HarvardX: Exercising Leadership: Foundational Principles: https://www.edx.org/learn/leadership/harvard-university-exercising-leadership-foundational-principles?utm_source=chatgpt.com

  • How to identify and unbundle complex challenges
  • How to understand the role of formal and informal authority
  • How to identify the key perspectives of stakeholders
  • How to build and renew trust relationships
  • How to approach conflict
  • How to implement personal strategies for surviving and thriving amidst change

HarvardX: Structure and Function of Argument: Introduction to Critical Thinking: https://www.edx.org/learn/philosophy-ethics/harvard-university-structure-and-function-of-argument-introduction-to-critical-thinking?utm_source=chatgpt.com

  • Analyze everyday arguments to boost communication skills.
  • Visually map arguments to strengthen reasoning.
  • Listen better and engage in respectful debate.
  • Use thought experiments to sharpen arguments.
  • Improve logic and EQ in tough conversations.
  • Spot assumptions and biases in arguments.
  • Stay curious and calm in disagreements.

PAID

Harvard: Disruptive Strategy: https://pll.harvard.edu/course/disruptive-strategy
Certificate

  • Become fluent in disruption theory and gain confidence in articulating complex viewpoints
  • Apply strategic frameworks to assess new opportunities and potential threats
  • Acquire techniques for executive-level strategy formulation and team management
  • Cohort learning

Harvard: Strategic Leadership: https://pll.harvard.edu/course/strategic-leadership
Certificate

  • Gain the insights, frameworks, and tools to inspire yourself and better lead your team and organization.
  • Learn how to ask better questions,
  • Leverage a diverse workforce
  • Address the complex problems your organization faces in new ways.
  • Cohort learning

Creators and Guests

Jeremy Ryan
Host
Jeremy Ryan
CIO at Polarity, having fun with innovation, creative technology, and AI (through hard word)
Jim Donio
Host
Jim Donio
CEO at Polarity, serial entrepreneur, equity partner, and award-winning leader in business innovation